Note AcademyNote Academy

Biology · May / June 2024 · Paper 11 · Question 7

YBI11

As printed in the paper

The question as text

7 Statins are used in the prevention and treatment of cardiovascular disease (CVD). Red yeast rice (RYR) is a source of food and medicine in Asia. It is produced by the fermentation of rice by yeast. Red yeast rice contains monacolin K, which is similar to a statin.

Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.

Show the answer and mark scheme
  • 7(a)[2]

    correct calculation (1)

    340 ÷ 45 = 7.555555555556

    e.g. 8 / 7.6 / 7.556 / 7.5556 etc

    7.56 (1)

    ACCEPT ecf 8.29

    Bald answer of 7.56 = 2 marks

    Bald answer of 8 / 7.6 / 7.556 /

    7.5556 etc / 8.29 = 1 mark

    *7(b)

    Table 1:

    NB A specific limitation / implication can only be awarded once

    RYR decreases total cholesterol
    RYR decreases LDL
    studies used different doses and decreases were not consistent
    which suggests other factors may be involved
    no indication of sample size / information about sex at birth, age, diet /where levels were measured, when levels were measured
    therefore valid conclusions cannot be drawn
    credit effect of limitation eg if person ate more cholesterol then decrease might be higher, levels measured closer to meal might be higher
    discrepancy on effects of HDL / not much data on HDL
    LDL : HDL ratio cannot be calculated
    and this is more significant than LDL / total cholesterol levels
    no indication of repeats
    so conclusions will not be valid
    no control group
    so cannot be certain that the RYR caused the changes

    Graph 1:

    RYR lowers LDL at both doses
    levels of LDL increase once RYR not taken anymore
    small sample size
    no indication of e.g. diet, age, sex at birth, when and where levels were measured
    therefore valid conclusions cannot be drawn
    credit effect of limitation eg if person ate more cholesterol then decrease might be higher, levels measured closer to meal might be higher
    {large / overlapping} {range bars / error bars}
    so conclusions will not be valid / RYR may have no significant effect
    short term study
    so don’t know if effects are long term

    Graph 2:

    taking RYR appears to decrease LDL
    {large / overlapping} {range bars / error bars}
    so conclusions will not be valid / RYR may have no significant effect
    no indication what the , what the dose was, what the time scale was
    credit specific effect of limitation eg if person ate more cholesterol then decrease might be higher,

    levels measured closer to meal might be higher, no timescale no indication of how long drop in LDL took

    Level 0

    0

    No awardable content

    Level 1

    12

    Demonstrates isolated elements of biological knowledge and

    Descriptions of data

    understanding to the given context with generalised comments made.

    Vague statements related to consequences are made with limited linkage

    1 mark = one description

    to a range of scientific ideas, processes, techniques and procedures. The

    2 marks = at least two descriptions of data from two

    discussion will contain basic information with some attempt made to link

    different sources of data

    knowledge and understanding to the given context.

    Level 2

    34

    Demonstrates adequate knowledge and understanding by selecting and

    Limitations of data

    applying some relevant biological facts / concepts. Consequences are

    discussed which are occasionally supported through linkage to a range of

    3 marks = one limitation described

    scientific ideas, processes, techniques and procedures. The discussion

    4 marks = at least two limitations described from two

    shows some linkages and lines of scientific reasoning with some

    different sources of data

    structure.

    Level 3

    56

    Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding by selecting

    Implications of limitation

    and applying relevant biological facts / concepts. Consequences are

    discussed which supported throughout by sustained linkage to a range of

    5 marks = one implication of one limitation given

    scientific ideas, processes, techniques and procedures. The discussion

    6 marks = at least one implication described for two

    shows a welldeveloped and sustained line of scientific reasoning which is

    limitations described from two different sources of data

    clear and logically structured.

  • 7(b)[6]

    correct calculation (1)

    340 ÷ 45 = 7.555555555556

    e.g. 8 / 7.6 / 7.556 / 7.5556 etc

    7.56 (1)

    ACCEPT ecf 8.29

    Bald answer of 7.56 = 2 marks

    Bald answer of 8 / 7.6 / 7.556 /

    7.5556 etc / 8.29 = 1 mark

    *7(b)

    Table 1:

    NB A specific limitation / implication can only be awarded once

    RYR decreases total cholesterol
    RYR decreases LDL
    studies used different doses and decreases were not consistent
    which suggests other factors may be involved
    no indication of sample size / information about sex at birth, age, diet /where levels were measured, when levels were measured
    therefore valid conclusions cannot be drawn
    credit effect of limitation eg if person ate more cholesterol then decrease might be higher, levels measured closer to meal might be higher
    discrepancy on effects of HDL / not much data on HDL
    LDL : HDL ratio cannot be calculated
    and this is more significant than LDL / total cholesterol levels
    no indication of repeats
    so conclusions will not be valid
    no control group
    so cannot be certain that the RYR caused the changes

    Graph 1:

    RYR lowers LDL at both doses
    levels of LDL increase once RYR not taken anymore
    small sample size
    no indication of e.g. diet, age, sex at birth, when and where levels were measured
    therefore valid conclusions cannot be drawn
    credit effect of limitation eg if person ate more cholesterol then decrease might be higher, levels measured closer to meal might be higher
    {large / overlapping} {range bars / error bars}
    so conclusions will not be valid / RYR may have no significant effect
    short term study
    so don’t know if effects are long term

    Graph 2:

    taking RYR appears to decrease LDL
    {large / overlapping} {range bars / error bars}
    so conclusions will not be valid / RYR may have no significant effect
    no indication what the , what the dose was, what the time scale was
    credit specific effect of limitation eg if person ate more cholesterol then decrease might be higher,

    levels measured closer to meal might be higher, no timescale no indication of how long drop in LDL took

    Level 0

    0

    No awardable content

    Level 1

    12

    Demonstrates isolated elements of biological knowledge and

    Descriptions of data

    understanding to the given context with generalised comments made.

    Vague statements related to consequences are made with limited linkage

    1 mark = one description

    to a range of scientific ideas, processes, techniques and procedures. The

    2 marks = at least two descriptions of data from two

    discussion will contain basic information with some attempt made to link

    different sources of data

    knowledge and understanding to the given context.

    Level 2

    34

    Demonstrates adequate knowledge and understanding by selecting and

    Limitations of data

    applying some relevant biological facts / concepts. Consequences are

    discussed which are occasionally supported through linkage to a range of

    3 marks = one limitation described

    scientific ideas, processes, techniques and procedures. The discussion

    4 marks = at least two limitations described from two

    shows some linkages and lines of scientific reasoning with some

    different sources of data

    structure.

    Level 3

    56

    Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding by selecting

    Implications of limitation

    and applying relevant biological facts / concepts. Consequences are

    discussed which supported throughout by sustained linkage to a range of

    5 marks = one implication of one limitation given

    scientific ideas, processes, techniques and procedures. The discussion

    6 marks = at least one implication described for two

    shows a welldeveloped and sustained line of scientific reasoning which is

    limitations described from two different sources of data

    clear and logically structured.

    credit two from:

    headache

    pins and needles

    hair loss

    acne

    allergic reaction / rash / hives

    dizziness

    memory loss / confusion

    feeling sick / nausea / vomiting

    feeling unusually tired / fatigue / physically weak

    stomach pain

    digestive system problems, such as constipation, diarrhoea,

    indigestion or farting

    loss of appetite

    (type II) diabetes

    impotence

    muscle {pain / tiredness / weakness / damage}

    joint {pain / swelling}

    tendon problems

    sleep problems

    low blood platelet count

    liver damage / hepatitis / yellowing of {eyes / skin} / darkcoloured

    urine

    kidney failure

    A description that makes reference to four of the following points:

    large group of people (1)

    ACCEPT minimum size of 100

    people who are {healthy / have no known illnesses} (1)

    ACCEPT not taking other medications

    DO NOT ACCEPT patients

    {control / same} {age / sex at birth / ethnicity / lifestyle / etc}

    DO NOT ACCEPT contradictions

    one group given placebo and one given monacolin K (1)

    ACCEPT given a control (substance)

    IGNORE use of different doses

    monitored for side effects (1)

    ACCEPT over a period of time

    minimum of a month

    statistical analysis of data (on side effects) / T test (1)

    ACCEPT analysis of MannWhitney U /

    Z test / standard deviation

    An answer that makes reference to two of the following points:

    difficult to eliminate the effects of a named factor that

    e.g. diet, activity levels

    cannot be controlled (1)

    psychological effects / placebo effect / assumption that they

    are taking monacolin (1)

    cannot quantify the extent of the side effect (1)

    ACCEPT assessment of side effect

    is subjective

    different people may react differently to the drug (1)

    ACCEPT people are genetically

    different

    side effects may not affect

    the group of people in the study

    ethics of giving someone an untested drug (1)

    ACCEPT moral / not right for

    ethical

    side effects could be fatal

    some side effects may {be rare / occur after a long period of

    time / not be detected} (1)

  • 7(c)(i)[1]

    credit two from:

    headache

    pins and needles

    hair loss

    acne

    allergic reaction / rash / hives

    dizziness

    memory loss / confusion

    feeling sick / nausea / vomiting

    feeling unusually tired / fatigue / physically weak

    stomach pain

    digestive system problems, such as constipation, diarrhoea,

    indigestion or farting

    loss of appetite

    (type II) diabetes

    impotence

    muscle {pain / tiredness / weakness / damage}

    joint {pain / swelling}

    tendon problems

    sleep problems

    low blood platelet count

    liver damage / hepatitis / yellowing of {eyes / skin} / darkcoloured

    urine

    kidney failure

  • 7(c)(ii)[4]

    A description that makes reference to four of the following points:

    large group of people (1)

    ACCEPT minimum size of 100

    people who are {healthy / have no known illnesses} (1)

    ACCEPT not taking other medications

    DO NOT ACCEPT patients

    {control / same} {age / sex at birth / ethnicity / lifestyle / etc}

    DO NOT ACCEPT contradictions

    one group given placebo and one given monacolin K (1)

    ACCEPT given a control (substance)

    IGNORE use of different doses

    monitored for side effects (1)

    ACCEPT over a period of time

    minimum of a month

    statistical analysis of data (on side effects) / T test (1)

    ACCEPT analysis of MannWhitney U /

    Z test / standard deviation

  • 7(c)(iii)[2]

    An answer that makes reference to two of the following points:

    difficult to eliminate the effects of a named factor that

    e.g. diet, activity levels

    cannot be controlled (1)

    psychological effects / placebo effect / assumption that they

    are taking monacolin (1)

    cannot quantify the extent of the side effect (1)

    ACCEPT assessment of side effect

    is subjective

    different people may react differently to the drug (1)

    ACCEPT people are genetically

    different

    side effects may not affect

    the group of people in the study

    ethics of giving someone an untested drug (1)

    ACCEPT moral / not right for

    ethical

    side effects could be fatal

    some side effects may {be rare / occur after a long period of

    time / not be detected} (1)

Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.