Biology · Oct / Nov 2023 · Paper 21 · Question 5
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
5 The lack of some inorganic ions in soil can affect the yield of fruit from crop plants.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
5(a)(i)[1]
An explanation that makes reference to the following points:
magnesium (ions) are needed for the formation of
accept magnesium (ions) are needed for
{chlorophyll / chloroplasts} (1)
{activation of enzymes / protein
synthesis}
(yellow leaves are due to) {fewer / no} {chlorophyll
less Mg=less chlorophyll = mp1&2
(molecules) / chloroplasts / green pigments} (1)
less chlorophyll linked to magnesium =
mp1&2
accept fewer activated enzymes
(reduced growth is due to) {reduced / no} {production of
accept {no/reduced} {metabolic
glucose / carbohydrate / photosynthesis} (1) need clear
reactions / respiration} if linked to the
statement
mp1AG only
Answers will be credited according to candidate’s deployment of knowledge and understanding of the material in relation to the
qualities and skills outlined in the generic mark scheme.
The indicative content below is not prescriptive and candidates are not required to include all the material indicated as relevant.
Additional content included in the response must be scientific and relevant.
there is (a greater) increase in mean leaf area with eggshells / increase is exponential with eggshells
similar increase in mean leaf area from day 1017 (for vine plants with and without eggshells)
there is (a greater) increase in {mean shoot length / growth} with eggshells
1&2
similar increase in mean shoot length from day 1025 (for vine plants with and without eggshells)
there is a greater chlorophyll content with eggshells
no data from leaf area / shoot length beyond {5255} days
relevant comment on {error/SD} bars e.g. overlap between xxx and xxx therefore no significant difference / no overlap between
xxx and xxx therefore significant difference / correct comment about error bar size linked to {reliability / validity}
(because crushed eggshells contain) calcium (ions) needed to form calcium pectate
3
calcium pectate {joins adjacent cells together / involved in forming middle lamella}
greater leaf area results in more {chlorophyll / chloroplasts/ light absorption}
greater leaf area results in increased photosynthesis
4
more {chlorophyll / light absorption} results in increased photosynthesis
increased {shoot/growth} results in more {light absorption / photosynthesis}
more photosynthesis results in more growth
more {photosynthesis / chlorophyll} results in more {glucose production / chemical energy store}
5
more glucose results in more growth
{glucose / chemical energy store} can be used in {respiration to provide ATP} / ATP needed for mitosis
6
glucose can be converted into {amino acids / glycerol}
increased protein synthesis would result in increased {growth / fruit production/chlorophyll production} only need increased once
7
(increased) calcium pectate would result in (increased) {growth of {plant / leaves} / support / strength / stability}
cost of adding eggshells / comparison of cost with traditional fertiliser
8
eggshells {more sustainable (as using waste product) / renewable resource / biodegradable} / deter pests such as slugs
Level 0
0
No awardable content
Level 1
12
Demonstrates isolated elements of biological knowledge
description of data
and understanding to the given context with generalised
1 mark – description of at least one graph
comments made.
2 marks – description of at least two graphs
Vague statements related to consequences are made with
limited linkage to a range of scientific ideas, processes,
techniques and procedures.
The discussion will contain basic information with some
attempt made to link knowledge and understanding to the
given context.
Level 2
34
Demonstrates adequate knowledge and understanding by
Level 1 plus linkages of chlorophyll content/leaf
selecting and applying some relevant biological facts /
area/shoot length to light absorption or
concepts.
photosynthesis
Consequences are discussed which are occasionally
plus linkage of calcium ions to calcium pectate
supported through linkage to a range of scientific ideas,
processes, techniques and procedures.
The discussion shows some linkages and lines of scientific
reasoning with some structure.
Level 3
56
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and
Level 2 plus consideration of the benefits of
understanding by selecting and applying relevant biological
increased {glucose/protein/calcium pectate} to the
facts / concepts.
plant and the cost involved / other benefits of
Consequences are discussed which supported throughout
eggshells
by sustained linkage to a range of scientific ideas, processes,
techniques and procedures.
The discussion shows a welldeveloped and sustained line of
scientific reasoning which is clear and logically structured.
5(a)(ii)[3]
An explanation that makes reference to the following points:
magnesium (ions) are needed for the formation of
accept magnesium (ions) are needed for
{chlorophyll / chloroplasts} (1)
{activation of enzymes / protein
synthesis}
(yellow leaves are due to) {fewer / no} {chlorophyll
less Mg=less chlorophyll = mp1&2
(molecules) / chloroplasts / green pigments} (1)
less chlorophyll linked to magnesium =
mp1&2
accept fewer activated enzymes
(reduced growth is due to) {reduced / no} {production of
accept {no/reduced} {metabolic
glucose / carbohydrate / photosynthesis} (1) need clear
reactions / respiration} if linked to the
statement
mp1AG only
5(b)[6]
Answers will be credited according to candidate’s deployment of knowledge and understanding of the material in relation to the
qualities and skills outlined in the generic mark scheme.
The indicative content below is not prescriptive and candidates are not required to include all the material indicated as relevant.
Additional content included in the response must be scientific and relevant.
there is (a greater) increase in mean leaf area with eggshells / increase is exponential with eggshells
similar increase in mean leaf area from day 1017 (for vine plants with and without eggshells)
there is (a greater) increase in {mean shoot length / growth} with eggshells
1&2
similar increase in mean shoot length from day 1025 (for vine plants with and without eggshells)
there is a greater chlorophyll content with eggshells
no data from leaf area / shoot length beyond {5255} days
relevant comment on {error/SD} bars e.g. overlap between xxx and xxx therefore no significant difference / no overlap between
xxx and xxx therefore significant difference / correct comment about error bar size linked to {reliability / validity}
(because crushed eggshells contain) calcium (ions) needed to form calcium pectate
3
calcium pectate {joins adjacent cells together / involved in forming middle lamella}
greater leaf area results in more {chlorophyll / chloroplasts/ light absorption}
greater leaf area results in increased photosynthesis
4
more {chlorophyll / light absorption} results in increased photosynthesis
increased {shoot/growth} results in more {light absorption / photosynthesis}
more photosynthesis results in more growth
more {photosynthesis / chlorophyll} results in more {glucose production / chemical energy store}
5
more glucose results in more growth
{glucose / chemical energy store} can be used in {respiration to provide ATP} / ATP needed for mitosis
6
glucose can be converted into {amino acids / glycerol}
increased protein synthesis would result in increased {growth / fruit production/chlorophyll production} only need increased once
7
(increased) calcium pectate would result in (increased) {growth of {plant / leaves} / support / strength / stability}
cost of adding eggshells / comparison of cost with traditional fertiliser
8
eggshells {more sustainable (as using waste product) / renewable resource / biodegradable} / deter pests such as slugs
Level 0
0
No awardable content
Level 1
12
Demonstrates isolated elements of biological knowledge
description of data
and understanding to the given context with generalised
1 mark – description of at least one graph
comments made.
2 marks – description of at least two graphs
Vague statements related to consequences are made with
limited linkage to a range of scientific ideas, processes,
techniques and procedures.
The discussion will contain basic information with some
attempt made to link knowledge and understanding to the
given context.
Level 2
34
Demonstrates adequate knowledge and understanding by
Level 1 plus linkages of chlorophyll content/leaf
selecting and applying some relevant biological facts /
area/shoot length to light absorption or
concepts.
photosynthesis
Consequences are discussed which are occasionally
plus linkage of calcium ions to calcium pectate
supported through linkage to a range of scientific ideas,
processes, techniques and procedures.
The discussion shows some linkages and lines of scientific
reasoning with some structure.
Level 3
56
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and
Level 2 plus consideration of the benefits of
understanding by selecting and applying relevant biological
increased {glucose/protein/calcium pectate} to the
facts / concepts.
plant and the cost involved / other benefits of
Consequences are discussed which supported throughout
eggshells
by sustained linkage to a range of scientific ideas, processes,
techniques and procedures.
The discussion shows a welldeveloped and sustained line of
scientific reasoning which is clear and logically structured.
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

