Biology · Oct / Nov 2022 · Paper 61 · Question 3
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
3 The photograph shows one variety of wheat and the grains it produces. (Source: © Li Ding/Alamy Stock Photo) A scientist observed that the germination of wheat grains was affected by the presence of arsenic ions in the soil. Groups of 30 grains were placed on filter paper in Petri dishes. Each Petri dish had 0.5 cm3 of water with a different concentration of arsenic ions added. The Petri dishes were incubated at 23 °C for four days. The percentage of seeds that germinated was recorded. The procedure was repeated a number of times.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
3(a)(i)[2]
Any reasonable risk identified
suitable risk identified (1)
eg toxic effects, allergy, irritant
ignore infection/labcoat/PPE
suitable control identified (1)
Any corresponding control identified eg use of
gloves/mask
3(a)(ii)[1]
there is no (significant) correlation between the
(mean) percentage of germination (after 4
days) and the concentration of arsenic ions
3(a)(iii)[3]
An answer that includes three of the following:
axes labelled including units (1)
Accept y axis mean % germination and x axis
concentration of arsenic ions/ mg dm3
data plotted correctly on a linear scale in scatter
Accept broken scale with symbol or scale not starting at
graph format (1)
zero Ignore line if drawn
error bars correctly plotted (1)
Example graph
concentration /mg
mean %
error
dm3
bar
0.0
100
0.5
84 ± 2
82 86
1.0
85± 2
83 87
2.0
81± 6
75 87
4.0
77 ± 8
69 85
8.0
65 ±14
51 79
16.0
66 ± 2
64 68
Example graph y axis not at zero
3(b)(i)[2]
calculation of intermediate step (1)
Accept Σd2 = 24 and n=7
OR 6 Σd2 = 24
n(n2 1) 336
13/14
rs = 0.929 / 0.93 / 0.9/0.9286
calculation of rs (1)
must be correct rounding
correct answer with no working gains full marks
3(b)(ii)[3]
An answer that includes three of the following:
calculated value (0.93) is greater than the critical
Accept 0.93 > 0.786, so reject the null hypothesis
value, 0.786 therefore reject the null hypothesis (1)
Accept critical value identified in table only
Accept a correct statement using the critical value
from p = 0.01
there is a (significant) correlation between the
Accept converse wording for MP1 And 2 if they
percentage germination and the concentration of
claim the calculated value is less than….
arsenic ions (1)
Eg error/range bars overlap
comment on variability of data (1)
3(c)(i)[2]
An answer that includes two of the following:
differences in {alleles/DNA} (may alter the
Ignore genes
response to arsenic ions) (1)
some varieties may be unable to absorb arsenic
Accept comment on membrane permeability
ions (during germination/in 4 days) (1)
reference to mutation/natural selection (1)
Accept details of one form of mutation
3(c)(ii)[3]
An answer that includes three of the following:
Ignore soil
germinate seeds with no arsenic (1)
(grown in) different concentrations of arsenic
Eg temperature, volume of water, light , pH
ions (1)
control of a stated condition (1)
accept other suitable parameter
eg 7100 days
measure {height/mass} of plants after
{stated/same length of time} (1)
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

