Biology · Oct / Nov 2022 · Paper 31 · Question 3
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
3 Onion plants can be grown in a laboratory in a complete mineral ion solution. This solution contains all the mineral ions required for healthy growth. The diagram shows a young onion plant. shoot bulb root
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
3(a)(i)[4]
An answer that includes the following
points:
description of the use of all threeNo mark if growing in soil
solutions to grow onions (1)
e.g. age, variety (ignore species) NOT size
as it is DV
description of a relevant bioticfactor kept constant (1)
e.g., light/ temperature / pH of solution
description of a relevant abioticfactor kept constant (1)
e.g. height, length, mass
appropriate measurement of {plantAccept if it is clear all started at same
parts / plant} made at start and
height/mass etc. / if measure difference
finish (1)
or increase in height / mass etc.
if time quoted must be a week minimum
after {same/ specified / stated}time (1)
3(a)(ii)[2]
An answer that includes the following
steps:
correct values from graph correctlye.g. 5g for shoot + bulb, 6.2 g for total
manipulated (1)
e.g. 80.6 (%)
correct percentage (1)correct with no working gains both marks
allow even if not in table
if no working allow correct answer which
is incorrectly rounded for 1 mark (80.64 or
81)
3(a)(iii)[3]
An answer that includes the following
points:
as solution concentration goes upAccept higher / est (for all parts) in ½
strength
growth (of all parts) goes down (1)
Accept lower / est (for all parts) in 2x
strength
Accept reverse argument
Allow description of relative effects, e.g.
the effect of solution concentrationon mass is {greatest in shoots / least
percentage increase in bulbs greatest
in roots} (1)
percentage edible is unaffected /ALLOW double strength solution reduces
little affected by solution
edible percentage or reverse
concentration (1)
Allow ecf if aii wrong
3(a)(iv)[3]
A description that includes three of the
following points:
grow several plants in each solutionAccept repeat experiment
calculation of (means and) SDs (1)check for overlap (of means plus andALLOW accept ranges, error bars in place
of SD
minus SD) for each difference (1)
expert (3)
carry out a statistical test (1)ALLOW t test, ignore Chi, correlation
3(b)[2]
An answer that includes the following
points:
Accept don’t add KH2PO4 / use solution
remove potassium hydrogenphosphate (1)
without KH2PO4
Ignore remove phosphate ions
replace potassium removed / addAccept idea that as there is KNO3 there is
extra of named salt to adjust
balance (1)
no need to do anything but remove KH2PO4
3(c)[4]
An answer that includes the following
points:
because this is the highest (uptake)of all mineral ions
{below 6.5 / at 8.08.5} phosphate inshort supply / {above 8.0 / below
5.5} nitrate in short supply (1)
e.g ATP, DNA, RNA, nucleotides,
cell division, energy exchange,
needed for appropriate {substance/process} (1)
protein synthesis.
Allow ecf from mp2
pH {above / below} this range willdenature enzymes (1)
Pearson Education Limited. Registered company number 872828
with its registered office at 80 Strand, London, WC2R 0RL, United Kingdom
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

