Biology · Oct / Nov 2022 · Paper 21 · Question 7
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
7 Great lakes and crater lakes can be found in Nicaragua, a country in Central America. These two types of lake differ in their species richness.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
7(a)[1]
accept {amount / variety} of species in an
the number of species within a {defined region /
area
habitat / community}.
do not accept number of organisms in a
species in a given area
7(b)[6]
Answers will be credited according to candidate’s deployment of knowledge and understanding of the material in relation
to the qualities and skills outlined in the generic mark scheme.
The indicative content below is not prescriptive, and candidates are not required to include all the material indicated as
relevant. Additional content included in the response must be scientific and relevant.
New species formation
reproductive / geographical isolation
due to cichlid population being {separated / entrapped} into different lakes / isolation can occur in different habitats
within same lake
recognition that Apoyo was first inhabited before Xiloá
recognition that cichlids can move between the two great lakes but not between the crater lakes
mutation causes new allele / genetic variation in original cichlid population
selection pressures different in different lakes
different alleles may give selective advantage in different lakes
fish with advantageous alleles survive, reproduce and pass these alleles onto their offspring
description of allele frequency increasing
different phenotypes developed due to different genotype
speciation first occurred in lake Apoyo / link to {long time/ 1000 years +} for first speciation to occur in lake {Apoyo /
Xiloá}
Determination of 6 different species
analysing phenotype similarities and differences
examples from photographs given
analysing biological molecules using molecular phylogeny e.g. DNA, RNA, proteins
details of methodology used to analyse the molecules
cichlids are different species as no longer able to breed together to produce fertile offspring
due to different {body shape / breeding behaviours etc}
discussion of how the molecular phylogeny results would support the cichlids being different species
Level 0
0
No awardable content
Level 1
12
Demonstrates isolated elements of biological knowledge related to
Basic description of either how the new species may
the given context with generalised comments made.
have formed in these four lakes
or
The description will contain basic information with some attempt
how the scientists would have determined that
made to link knowledge and understanding to the given context.
these cichlids were 6 different species
Level 2
34
Demonstrates adequate knowledge by selecting and applying
Basic description of new species formation and
some relevant biological facts/concepts to provide the description
determination of new species
being presented.
or
Detailed description of new species formation
The description shows some linkages and lines of reasoning with
some structure.
Level 3
56
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge by selecting and
Detailed description of either how the new species
applying relevant knowledge of biological facts/concepts to
may have formed in these four lakes
provide the description being presented.
And
how the scientists would have determined that
The description is clear, coherent and logically structured.
these cichlids were 6 different species
7(c)[4]
An answer that includes the following points:
Species
Number of
n(n1)
individuals
N(N1) correctly calculated (1)(n)
A. astorquii
156
24180
∑n(n1) correctly calculated and inserted into formula (1)A. chancho
45
1980
A. flaveolus
78
6006
calculation of D for lake Apoyo (1)A. globosus
8
56
A.
17
272
lake Apoyo has higher biodiversity (as 3.05 is larger than 2.8)supercilius
A. zaliosus
12
132
(N)=316
∑n(n
1)=32626
D= 3.0509 / 3.05 / 3.051 / 3.1 / 3.0 / 3
ecf applies
7(d)[3]
An answer that includes the following points:
q2 correctly calculated (1)128÷800 or = 0.16
(√p²=0.6 and) √q²=0.4 (1)no ecf
allele frequency has {not changed / remained the same} (1)ecf applies from incorrect p and q values
in working
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

