Note AcademyNote Academy

Biology · May / June 2022 · Paper 61 · Question 3

YBI11

As printed in the paper

The question as text

3 The photograph shows a sunflower plant, Helianthus annuus. (Source: © Richard Griffin/Alamy Stock Photo) A student investigated the effect that wind had on the bending of plants. Thirty sunflower plants were grown in individual pots until they were 60 cm tall. The leaves and flowers were removed from the sunflower plants. For one group of 15 plants, the top of each stem was bent by 10 cm and then released as shown in the diagram. Stem bent by 10 cm The bending of the stems was repeated once a day for eight weeks. A control group of 15 plants were kept in the same conditions but without the stems being bent. The diameter of the stem at the base of each plant was measured after eight weeks.

Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.

Show the answer and mark scheme
  • 3(a)[1]

    There is no (significant) difference

    Accept no difference between the diameters of the two groups

    between the diameter of control

    stems and experimental stems

  • 3(b)[3]

    Example table

    Stem diameter /

    suitable table format with data (1)

    mm

    Control

    Bent

    correct column headings with units (1)

    stems

    stems

    17.15

    17.34

    means correctly calculated (1)

    17.52

    18.16

    17.57

    17.61

    17.03

    18.14

    17.26

    17.64

    17.31

    18.14

    17.09

    17.95

    17.38

    17.78

    17.41

    17.69

    17.21

    17.84

    17.34

    17.99

    17.16

    17.95

    17.15

    17.89

    17.32

    18.16

    17.60

    18.22

    17.3(0)

    17.9(0)

    Not 17 18 as mean values

    Means can be to two places or one but not mixed / Means do not have to

    be in the table

    Ignore errors in table data eg 17.6 instead of 17.60

    Not MP2 if units in the body of the table

  • 3(c)[3]

    bar graph with labels, units and linear scale (1)

    mean diameter /mm and group / eq

    BAR GRAPH MUST START AT ZERO AND NO BROKEN SCALE

    means plotted correctly (1)

    Allow ECF from 3bi

    range bars plotted correctly (1)

    17.34 18.22

    17.03 17.60

    MP2 and 3 can be awarded for line graph

    3di

    Allow wrong means used for2 marks

    correct substitution of given (SA)2 and (SB)2 (1)

    ie 0.03 and 0.06

    correct answer (1)

    7.75

    Accept 7.746 / 7.7459

    MP2 only for 34.6 / 34.64 / 34.641

    3d ii

    Allow use of any quoted value as the calculated value

    (from3di so reverse statements

    the calculated value of t (7.75) is more than the

    Allow use of p=0.01 and critical value of 2.76

    critical value 2.05 (at p=0.05) (1)

    therefore reject the {null hypothesis/H0}, there is a

    Allow reverse statement if calculated value is stated /

    difference between the diameter of control and

    shown as less than 2.05

    experimental stems (1)

  • 3(d)(i)[2]

    There is no (significant) difference

    Accept no difference between the diameters of the two groups

    between the diameter of control

    stems and experimental stems

    Example table

    Stem diameter /

    suitable table format with data (1)

    mm

    Control

    Bent

    correct column headings with units (1)

    stems

    stems

    17.15

    17.34

    means correctly calculated (1)

    17.52

    18.16

    17.57

    17.61

    17.03

    18.14

    17.26

    17.64

    17.31

    18.14

    17.09

    17.95

    17.38

    17.78

    17.41

    17.69

    17.21

    17.84

    17.34

    17.99

    17.16

    17.95

    17.15

    17.89

    17.32

    18.16

    17.60

    18.22

    17.3(0)

    17.9(0)

    Not 17 18 as mean values

    Means can be to two places or one but not mixed / Means do not have to

    be in the table

    Ignore errors in table data eg 17.6 instead of 17.60

    Not MP2 if units in the body of the table

    bar graph with labels, units and linear scale (1)

    mean diameter /mm and group / eq

    BAR GRAPH MUST START AT ZERO AND NO BROKEN SCALE

    means plotted correctly (1)

    Allow ECF from 3bi

    range bars plotted correctly (1)

    17.34 18.22

    17.03 17.60

    MP2 and 3 can be awarded for line graph

    3di

    Allow wrong means used for2 marks

    correct substitution of given (SA)2 and (SB)2 (1)

    ie 0.03 and 0.06

    correct answer (1)

    7.75

    Accept 7.746 / 7.7459

    MP2 only for 34.6 / 34.64 / 34.641

    3d ii

    Allow use of any quoted value as the calculated value

    (from3di so reverse statements

    the calculated value of t (7.75) is more than the

    Allow use of p=0.01 and critical value of 2.76

    critical value 2.05 (at p=0.05) (1)

    therefore reject the {null hypothesis/H0}, there is a

    Allow reverse statement if calculated value is stated /

    difference between the diameter of control and

    shown as less than 2.05

    experimental stems (1)

    An explanation that includes two of the following:

    the {seeds/plants} may have been {different varieties /

    genetically different} (1)

    plants may bend for other reasons eg phototropism / light

    Ignore IAA/auxins

    direction (1)

    the range bars overlap

  • 3(d)(ii)[2]

    There is no (significant) difference

    Accept no difference between the diameters of the two groups

    between the diameter of control

    stems and experimental stems

    Example table

    Stem diameter /

    suitable table format with data (1)

    mm

    Control

    Bent

    correct column headings with units (1)

    stems

    stems

    17.15

    17.34

    means correctly calculated (1)

    17.52

    18.16

    17.57

    17.61

    17.03

    18.14

    17.26

    17.64

    17.31

    18.14

    17.09

    17.95

    17.38

    17.78

    17.41

    17.69

    17.21

    17.84

    17.34

    17.99

    17.16

    17.95

    17.15

    17.89

    17.32

    18.16

    17.60

    18.22

    17.3(0)

    17.9(0)

    Not 17 18 as mean values

    Means can be to two places or one but not mixed / Means do not have to

    be in the table

    Ignore errors in table data eg 17.6 instead of 17.60

    Not MP2 if units in the body of the table

    bar graph with labels, units and linear scale (1)

    mean diameter /mm and group / eq

    BAR GRAPH MUST START AT ZERO AND NO BROKEN SCALE

    means plotted correctly (1)

    Allow ECF from 3bi

    range bars plotted correctly (1)

    17.34 18.22

    17.03 17.60

    MP2 and 3 can be awarded for line graph

    3di

    Allow wrong means used for2 marks

    correct substitution of given (SA)2 and (SB)2 (1)

    ie 0.03 and 0.06

    correct answer (1)

    7.75

    Accept 7.746 / 7.7459

    MP2 only for 34.6 / 34.64 / 34.641

    3d ii

    Allow use of any quoted value as the calculated value

    (from3di so reverse statements

    the calculated value of t (7.75) is more than the

    Allow use of p=0.01 and critical value of 2.76

    critical value 2.05 (at p=0.05) (1)

    therefore reject the {null hypothesis/H0}, there is a

    Allow reverse statement if calculated value is stated /

    difference between the diameter of control and

    shown as less than 2.05

    experimental stems (1)

    An explanation that includes two of the following:

    the {seeds/plants} may have been {different varieties /

    genetically different} (1)

    plants may bend for other reasons eg phototropism / light

    Ignore IAA/auxins

    direction (1)

    the range bars overlap

  • 3(e)[2]

    An explanation that includes two of the following:

    the {seeds/plants} may have been {different varieties /

    genetically different} (1)

    plants may bend for other reasons eg phototropism / light

    Ignore IAA/auxins

    direction (1)

    the range bars overlap

Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.