Biology · May / June 2022 · Paper 41 · Question 5
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
5 The table shows the energy content in the three trophic levels of a food chain from an African plain. Trophic level Organism Energy content Lion 3 920 Gerenuk 2 8 825 Tree 1 90 480
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
5(a)(i)[1]
ACCEPT 98 : 9.6 : 1
98.3 : 9.6 : 1
100 : 10 : 1
98 : 10 : 1
10 : 1 : 0.1
10.3 : 1 : 0.1
1 : 0.1: 0.01
An explanation that includes the following points:
IGNORE no energy / biomass
because not enough energy (in trophic level 3) (1)
to sustain (organisms in) a fourth trophic level (1)
ACCEPT support
OR
energy is lost between trophic levels (1)
so not enough energy for another trophic level (1)
IGNORE no energy / biomass
A description that includes the following points:
breakdown organic matter (1)ACCEPT dead {tree / gerenuk /
lion} / tissues / named organic
molecule
with (hydrolytic) enzymes (1)ACCEPT named enzyme
NB release {digestive / hydrolytic}
enzymes onto dead organisms = 2
releasing carbon dioxide from respiration (to the atmosphere)where it is used for photosynthesis (by plants) (1)
Level 1 points:
Level 1:
due to natural selection
1 mark = 1 point made from any
(Descriptions of differences in features)
level
gerenuk’s food is higher up / springbok’s food is lower down
gerenuks have longer {necks / limbs}
2 marks = 3 points made from
gerenuk’s white areas are {underneath / more concealed}
any level
better adapted organisms survive and reproduce
passing their alleles onto their offspring
Level 2 points:
Level 2:
occupy a different niche because they eat different food
(Descriptions of how mutation caused a difference)
NB Must be a reference to the
change in length of {neck / limbs} due to a mutation
data / context of the question
change in type of horns due to a mutation
(Explanations of how a features are an adaptation / result in difference in behaviour)
3 marks = 4 points made which
organisms with longer neck could reach the higher leaves
include at least one level 2 point
organisms with smaller horns did not get caught up in branches
smaller organisms had to go to waterhole for water
4 marks = 5 points made which
organisms with larger horns could defend off predators
include at least one level 2 point
male gerenuks kept horns for fighting for females
reference to {reduced gene flow / change in allele frequency / reproductive isolation} with no links made
Level 3 points:
Level 3:
length of {neck / limbs} is a polygenic characteristic
type of horns is a polygenic characteristic
NB Horns and {leg / neck}
therefore organisms will show (continuous) variation for this phenotype
length must be included
height of food acted as a selection pressure on size
5 marks = 6 points made which
{branches / predators} acted as a selection pressure on horns
includes at least one level 3
organisms that {occupy a different niche / feed on different food} are not in competition with each other
point
two groups of organisms moved apart depending on where their food was
sympatric speciation / organisms not separated by a physical barrier
6 marks = 7 points made which
therefore reduced gene flow (between the two groups)
includes at least one level 3
resulting in changes in the allele frequency
point
eventually resulting in reproductively isolated
and the formation of two species
5(a)(ii)[1]
ACCEPT 98 : 9.6 : 1
98.3 : 9.6 : 1
100 : 10 : 1
98 : 10 : 1
10 : 1 : 0.1
10.3 : 1 : 0.1
1 : 0.1: 0.01
An explanation that includes the following points:
IGNORE no energy / biomass
because not enough energy (in trophic level 3) (1)
to sustain (organisms in) a fourth trophic level (1)
ACCEPT support
OR
energy is lost between trophic levels (1)
so not enough energy for another trophic level (1)
IGNORE no energy / biomass
A description that includes the following points:
breakdown organic matter (1)ACCEPT dead {tree / gerenuk /
lion} / tissues / named organic
molecule
with (hydrolytic) enzymes (1)ACCEPT named enzyme
NB release {digestive / hydrolytic}
enzymes onto dead organisms = 2
releasing carbon dioxide from respiration (to the atmosphere)where it is used for photosynthesis (by plants) (1)
Level 1 points:
Level 1:
due to natural selection
1 mark = 1 point made from any
(Descriptions of differences in features)
level
gerenuk’s food is higher up / springbok’s food is lower down
gerenuks have longer {necks / limbs}
2 marks = 3 points made from
gerenuk’s white areas are {underneath / more concealed}
any level
better adapted organisms survive and reproduce
passing their alleles onto their offspring
Level 2 points:
Level 2:
occupy a different niche because they eat different food
(Descriptions of how mutation caused a difference)
NB Must be a reference to the
change in length of {neck / limbs} due to a mutation
data / context of the question
change in type of horns due to a mutation
(Explanations of how a features are an adaptation / result in difference in behaviour)
3 marks = 4 points made which
organisms with longer neck could reach the higher leaves
include at least one level 2 point
organisms with smaller horns did not get caught up in branches
smaller organisms had to go to waterhole for water
4 marks = 5 points made which
organisms with larger horns could defend off predators
include at least one level 2 point
male gerenuks kept horns for fighting for females
reference to {reduced gene flow / change in allele frequency / reproductive isolation} with no links made
Level 3 points:
Level 3:
length of {neck / limbs} is a polygenic characteristic
type of horns is a polygenic characteristic
NB Horns and {leg / neck}
therefore organisms will show (continuous) variation for this phenotype
length must be included
height of food acted as a selection pressure on size
5 marks = 6 points made which
{branches / predators} acted as a selection pressure on horns
includes at least one level 3
organisms that {occupy a different niche / feed on different food} are not in competition with each other
point
two groups of organisms moved apart depending on where their food was
sympatric speciation / organisms not separated by a physical barrier
6 marks = 7 points made which
therefore reduced gene flow (between the two groups)
includes at least one level 3
resulting in changes in the allele frequency
point
eventually resulting in reproductively isolated
and the formation of two species
5(a)(iii)[1]
ACCEPT 98 : 9.6 : 1
98.3 : 9.6 : 1
100 : 10 : 1
98 : 10 : 1
10 : 1 : 0.1
10.3 : 1 : 0.1
1 : 0.1: 0.01
5(a)(iv)[2]
An explanation that includes the following points:
IGNORE no energy / biomass
because not enough energy (in trophic level 3) (1)
to sustain (organisms in) a fourth trophic level (1)
ACCEPT support
OR
energy is lost between trophic levels (1)
so not enough energy for another trophic level (1)
IGNORE no energy / biomass
5(a)(v)[3]
A description that includes the following points:
breakdown organic matter (1)ACCEPT dead {tree / gerenuk /
lion} / tissues / named organic
molecule
with (hydrolytic) enzymes (1)ACCEPT named enzyme
NB release {digestive / hydrolytic}
enzymes onto dead organisms = 2
releasing carbon dioxide from respiration (to the atmosphere)where it is used for photosynthesis (by plants) (1)
5(b)[6]
Level 1 points:
Level 1:
due to natural selection
1 mark = 1 point made from any
(Descriptions of differences in features)
level
gerenuk’s food is higher up / springbok’s food is lower down
gerenuks have longer {necks / limbs}
2 marks = 3 points made from
gerenuk’s white areas are {underneath / more concealed}
any level
better adapted organisms survive and reproduce
passing their alleles onto their offspring
Level 2 points:
Level 2:
occupy a different niche because they eat different food
(Descriptions of how mutation caused a difference)
NB Must be a reference to the
change in length of {neck / limbs} due to a mutation
data / context of the question
change in type of horns due to a mutation
(Explanations of how a features are an adaptation / result in difference in behaviour)
3 marks = 4 points made which
organisms with longer neck could reach the higher leaves
include at least one level 2 point
organisms with smaller horns did not get caught up in branches
smaller organisms had to go to waterhole for water
4 marks = 5 points made which
organisms with larger horns could defend off predators
include at least one level 2 point
male gerenuks kept horns for fighting for females
reference to {reduced gene flow / change in allele frequency / reproductive isolation} with no links made
Level 3 points:
Level 3:
length of {neck / limbs} is a polygenic characteristic
type of horns is a polygenic characteristic
NB Horns and {leg / neck}
therefore organisms will show (continuous) variation for this phenotype
length must be included
height of food acted as a selection pressure on size
5 marks = 6 points made which
{branches / predators} acted as a selection pressure on horns
includes at least one level 3
organisms that {occupy a different niche / feed on different food} are not in competition with each other
point
two groups of organisms moved apart depending on where their food was
sympatric speciation / organisms not separated by a physical barrier
6 marks = 7 points made which
therefore reduced gene flow (between the two groups)
includes at least one level 3
resulting in changes in the allele frequency
point
eventually resulting in reproductively isolated
and the formation of two species
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

