Note AcademyNote Academy

Biology · May / June 2022 · Paper 21 · Question 5

YBI11

As printed in the paper

The question as text

5 The Hawaiian islands have 18 species of honeycreeper birds. The Hawaii amakihi honeycreeper and the Hawaii palila honeycreeper are two species found on these islands.

Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.

Show the answer and mark scheme
  • 5(a)(i)[1]

    The only correct answer is B endemic

    A is not correct because the correct term is endemic

    C is not correct because the correct term is endemic

    D is not correct because the correct term is endemic

  • 5(a)(ii)[2]

    A calculation in which:

    Example of calculation:

    correct difference (1)

    9507100 = ()6150

    correct percentage change (1)

    (6150 ÷7100) x 100 = ()87(%)

    Correct answer scores full marks

  • 5(b)[6]

    Answers will be credited according to candidate’s deployment of knowledge and understanding of the material in relation

    to the qualities and skills outlined in the generic mark scheme.

    The indicative content below is not prescriptive and candidates are not required to include all the material indicated as

    relevant. Additional content included in the response must be scientific and relevant.

    common ancestor {lived on Hawaii islands / had shorter beak than Amakihi / less powerful beak than Palila}

    colonisation of new island / geographical isolation

    change in the environment / competition for food / (new) selection pressures

    genetic variation in population / mutation resulted in new allele(s)

    some alleles conferred an advantage therefore bird more likely to survive and reproduce than other birds and pass

    on those advantageous alleles to next generation

    repeated over many generations leading to new species

    idea of reproductive isolation

    Amakihi

    Amakihi has a longer beak

    (therefore) was able to drink (more) nectar from flowers / tree sap / access more spiders / insects

    Amakihi has larger population due to being adapted to live in more habitats / idea that it can access more types of

    food sources

    Palila

    Palila has a {more powerful beak / beak which could crack open the coat (of seed)}

    Palila was able to eat (more) seeds / berries

    Level 0

    0

    No awardable content

    Level 1

    12

    An explanation may be attempted but with limited

    evolution of generic new species explained with

    interpretation or analysis of the scientific information and

    basic information

    with a focus on mainly just one piece of scientific

    1 mark – very limited explanation of evolution of a

    information.

    (generic) new species

    2 marks – more detailed explanation of evolution of

    The explanation will contain basic information, with some

    a (generic) new species OR one point about generic

    attempt made to link knowledge and understanding to the

    explanation plus a basic linkage to either Amakihi or

    given context.

    Palila

    Level 2

    34

    An explanation will be given, with occasional evidence of

    Level 1 plus some linkages to either Amakihi or

    analysis, interpretation and/or evaluation of both pieces of

    Palila

    scientific information.

    3 marks = basic linkage for one

    4 marks = detailed linkage for one or basic for both

    The explanation shows some linkages and lines of scientific

    reasoning, with some structure.

    Level 3

    56

    An explanation is made that is supported throughout by

    Level 2 plus detailed linkage to both Amakihi and

    sustained application of relevant evidence of analysis,

    Palila

    interpretation and/or evaluation of both pieces of scientific

    5 marks = detailed linkage for one and basic for one

    information.

    6 marks = detailed linkage for both

    The explanation shows a welldeveloped and sustained line

    of scientific reasoning, which is clear and logically structured.

  • 5(c)[2]

    An answer that makes reference to the following points:

    molecular phylogeny / analysis of (the sequences in) biological

    e.g. DNA, mRNA, proteins

    molecules (1)

    (therefore) the species with the {most similarities / fewest

    differences} (are the most closely related) (1)

Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.