Biology · Oct / Nov 2021 · Paper 31 · Question 2
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
2 Scientists investigated the effect of salts on the permeability of cell membranes of beetroot. The diagram shows a beetroot cell with a vacuole containing the red pigment betalain. cell wall vacuole membrane (tonoplast) cell surface membrane cytoplasm betalain nucleus Equal sized discs of tissue were cut from a beetroot. Twenty of these discs were placed into a beaker containing a calcium chloride solution. This was repeated for several concentrations of calcium chloride and several concentrations of ammonium sulfate. Betalain leaked from the discs, changing the colour of the solutions in the beakers. The intensity of each colour was recorded after 12 hours.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
2(a)(i)[3]
An explanation that includes the following points:
because the same {light source / filter / sizecuvette} used for all measurements (1)
because zeroing / calibrating (1)described
because objective measurement (1)because no light lost / gained (1)2(a)(ii)[2]
An answer that includes the following points :
temperature, use of thermostatically controlledaccept room
water bath / incubator (1)
pH, use of buffer (1)2(b)(i)[3]
Loss of betalain from beetroot
A table showing the following
cells / a.u.
features:
suitable table drawn (1)Concentration of
with
with calcium
salt / mmol dm‐3
ammonium
chloride
sulfate
headings with units (1)0.00000
0.30
0.30
all data correctly entered0.00025
0.46
0.29
0.00200
0.50
0.15
0.02000
0.47
0.02
Allow
0.00025 to 0.0003 second cell, first column
2(b)(ii)[3]
An answer including of the following points :
Similarities
both salts affect leakage (1)accept effect on
permeability
in both, greatest effect is over a small initialincrease in salt concentration (1)
Differences
calcium chloride causes {leakage / intensity offor calcium chloride
colour} to decrease, ammonium sulfate causes
inverse,
for ammonium sulfate
{leakage / intensity of colour} to increase,
direct relationship
(with increase in concentration) (1)
accept higher / lower
loss for {Ammonium
Sulfate / Calcium
Chloride}
a small initial change in ammonium sulfateconcentration causes a larger change in leakage
compared with a small initial change in calcium
chloride concentration (1)
2(b)(iii)[2]
An answer including the following steps :
allow ecf
figures read off graph for CaCl2 (A) ande.g.
(NH4)2SO4 (B), BA = C (1)
{0.48 / 0.49} 0.09 =
{0.39 / 0.40}
accept anything
between 0.48 and
C ÷ A × 100 = D (%) (1)0.49
0.39 ÷ 0.09 = 433 /
433.3 / 433.33 (%)
0.40 ÷ 0.09 = 444 /
444.4 / 444.44 (%)
OR
0.39 ÷ 0.49 = 80 /
79.6 / 79.59%
0.40 ÷ 0.49 = 82 /
81.6 / 81.63%
2(c)(i)[3]
An answer including the following points :
with calcium chloride and ammonium sulfatethe {leakage / permeability / intensity of
colour} is more than with calcium chloride
alone (1)
with ammonium sulfate, leakage increased(compared with water) (1)
accept increasing
{pattern is the same in both lines in secondcalcium chloride
experiment / described} (1)
conc. leads to
decrease in intensity
of colour (etc) with or
without ammonium
sulfate
accept correct figures
at 0.010 mmol dm3 calcium chloride alonequoted
{leakage / intensity of colour} is {equal / only
slightly different} to that with ammonium
sulfate with calcium chloride (1)
calcium chloride can reverse the effects ofammonium sulfate (on membranes) (1)
2(c)(ii)[3]
An answer including the following points :
repeat readings at 0.002 mmol dm3 (1)under same conditions (each time) (1)calculate (mean and) standard deviation (1)accept error bar
accept ref to SD
accept perform ttest
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

