Note AcademyNote Academy

Biology · Oct / Nov 2021 · Paper 11 · Question 5

YBI11

As printed in the paper

The question as text

5 Genetic screening can be used to test for aneuploidy. Aneuploidy is the presence of an abnormal number of chromosomes in a cell. Aneuploidy can affect the miscarriage rate of implanted embryos. Following screening, only embryos with the correct number of chromosomes are implanted into the female. The table shows the miscarriage rate of two groups of implanted embryos: • embryos not screened for aneuploidy • embryos screened and shown not to have aneuploidy. Miscarriage rate (%) Age range Implanted embryos Implanted embryos of women at not screened for screened and shown implantation / years aneuploidy not to have aneuploidy <35 12.0 11.2 35 to 37 16.8 13.0 38 to 40 25.0 13.6 41 to 42 37.9 16.3 >42 58.8 17.2

Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.

Show the answer and mark scheme
  • 5(a)[2]

    An explanation that includes the following points:

    because the rate of miscarriage increases with (increase in) age

    ACCEPT directly proportional to each

    other

    it shows that an increase in one

    variable is reflected by an increase in

    the other variable

    ACCEPT no evidence of causation

    there is no evidence age is causing the miscarriage (1)

  • 5(b)(i)[2]

    An explanation that includes the following points:

    ACCEPT converse where appropriate

    aneuploidy results in miscarriage because the screened embryos

    result in fewer miscarriages (1)

    e.g. age, mutations, the process of

    other {factors / named factor} cause miscarriages because

    {screened embryos / embryos that do not have aneuploidy} are

    implanting embryos, smoking, alcohol,

    miscarried (1)

    dietary factors

    IGNORE lifestyle / screening causes

    miscarriage

  • 5(b)(ii)[3]

    An explanation that includes three of the following points:

    ACCEPT small sample size

    because no indication of sample size (1)

    because no statistics presented (1)

    because no idea how many of the unscreened embryos had

    aneuploidy (1)

    IGNORE age / sex

    other {lifestyles / factors / named factor} not {taken into account

    / not shown} (1)

    false (negative / positive) results (1)

  • 5(c)[3]

    An answer that includes three of the following points:

    DO NOT ACCEPT {fetus / baby}

    (preimplantation) screened embryos still result in miscarriages so

    raising false hopes (1)

    e.g. discarding the embryos is unethical

    issues surrounding the embryos (that have aneuploidy) (1)

    ACCEPT false (negative) result leads to

    false (positive) results resulting in unnecessary {wastage /

    use of that embryo

    destruction} of embryos (1)

    other (genetic) defects may be found (1)

Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.