Biology · May / June 2021 · Paper 61 · Question 3
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
3 The photograph shows a sea slug of the genus Aplysia, a marine animal. external gills Magnification ×1.0 Aplysia can be kept in tanks in a laboratory. Aplysia absorb oxygen using external gills. When the gills are touched, the gills are completely withdrawn into the body by a reflex action. The gills re‑emerge after some time. The student formed the following hypothesis: The more frequently the gills are touched the less time it takes them to re‑emerge. Plan an investigation to find evidence to support or reject this hypothesis.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
3(a)[3]
A description that includes the following
Ignore stated methods –
points:
credit is for finding out
find a suitable method for
touching the external gills (1)
find suitable conditions that allow
Accept eg. temperature, light
the sea slugs to be active (1)
intensity
find a suitable method to decide
when the gills have reemerged
3(b)[10]
An answer that includes ten of the following points:
clear statement of the dependent variable e.g. (time
for) reemergence of gills (1)
Accept description of frequency of touches eg every 5
description of method to provide different number
minutes
of touches (1)
eg glass rod of same diameter
same person using same glass rod to touch with the
description of method for ensuring same intensity of
same force
each touch stimulation (1)
eg measure / sketch gills at start and refer to this
description of method for determining complete re
emergence of gills (1)
clear statement required
the method of touching the gills must not cause pain
/ damage (1)
the animals are given time to acclimatise {before
stimulation begins / between touches} (1)
eg water temperature, pH, salinity, depth of water, light
intensity, substrate
variables that need to be taken into account (2)
eg source / age / sex / species of Aplysia
description of how these variables are controlled (2)
Accept repeat with the same animal (after suitable
interval)
repeat whole experiment with different animals (1)
3(c)[4]
table with headings and units (1)
Headings: time for reemergence (accept minutes or
seconds) and number of touches
Accept description of table
means calculated from repeats (1)
Accept statement or column in table
Accept medians in place of mean
line graph format with labelled axes (1)
Accept description of graph
Accept named test eg Spearman Rank
use of an appropriate correlation statistical test (1)
3(d)[4]
difficult to standardise the touch affecting the withdrawal reflex
eg. pressure / force
possible errors in determining full reemergence (1)
difficult to control {age of animal / surface area of gills} (1)
accept sex of Aplysia
difficult to control other possible stimuli which may cause reflex
eg. sound, shadows, vibrations, water
currents
(Total for question 3 = 21)
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

