Biology · Oct / Nov 2020 · Paper 61 · Question 2
YBI11
As printed in the paper
The question as text
2 The photograph shows a thistle plant. (Source: © John Stacey) This plant grows in grassland and is not eaten by cattle. A student investigated the effect of treating thistle plants with a solution of insecticide. Other thistle plants were treated with water. All the thistle plants used were selected, at random, from the same field. After 56 days, the student measured the longest leaf of each thistle plant used in this investigation.
Read automatically from the paper; the printed page above is exact.
Show the answer and mark scheme
2(a)[1]
there will be no difference between the length of
leaves treated with insecticide or water (after 56 days)
2(b)(i)[1]
26 / 26.1 / 26.13 (%)
Allow 21 / 20.7 / 20.71
2(b)(ii)[3]
Length of leaf /cm
Insecticide
Water
treated
treated
12.6
9.1
13.1
9.4
suitable table format with data (1)
13.9
10.3
14.0
10.1
11.1
10.4
correct column headings with units (1)
11.6
10.9
means correctly calculated (1)
12.4
9.0
12.9
9.7
12.5
9.9
13.4
10.8
13.7
9.3
12.0
9.8
11.9
9.2
12.6
9.7
11.8
9.4
mean
12.6
9.8
2(c)[3]
ALLOW ECF from 2b axes mean length (cm)
bar graph with linear scale and axes labelled with unit (1)
and insecticide /water
means plotted correctly (1)
12.6 9.8
range bars plotted correctly (1)
1411.1 and 10.9 9.0
2(d)(i)[3]
numerator calculation or value shown (1)
= ‘insert calc’ / 2.8 OR ‘insert calc’ / 2.83
denominator calculation or value shown (1)
= ‘insert calc’ / 0.272 OR ‘insert calc’ / 0.273
t = 10.3 / 10.31 (1)
OR 10.4 / 10.37
Correct answer with no working gains full marks
2(d)(ii)[2]
An answer that includes two of the following points:
IGNORE other calculated values
critical value is 2.048 and the calculated value (10.31) is more than the
as long as they are greater than
2.048
critical value (1)
therefore reject the null hypothesis there is a difference between the
length of the leaf of insecticide treated and water treated( thistle plants)
range bars do not overlap
IGNORE reliability / accuracy /
comment on variability of data (1)
reliability / repeatability
2(e)[2]
An answer that includes two of the following points:
IGNORE different fields
the leaves should have been measured before the treatment (because
ALLOW measured from the
the rate of growth may be different) (1)
same part of the plant eg at a
specified height or 5th leaf down
ALLOW a named condition
the environmental conditions need to be controlled/measured
controlled/measured
(because they will affect the rate of growth) (1)
ALLOW in a greenhouse/eq Allow
a longer period of time
the leaves should have been measured at different {time interval(s) /
growth season} (to compare the rate of growth) (1)
use of different concentrations of insecticides (1)
(Total for question 2 = 15 marks)
Make a free account to save your answers and see your weak topics and ask the AI why a wrong answer is wrong.

